Daniel Hoffman On The Outages: “A Lack of Transparency Is A Real Problem”

Full Interview:

Full Transcript:

Guy Benson: We begin with Daniel Hoffman, who is a former CIA station chief. He served in Moscow, in Iraq, Pakistan, South Asia, Europe, all over the place. He is now a Fox News contributor. You can follow him on X or Twitter, at DanielHoffmanDC. Dan, great to have you back.

Daniel Hoffman:
Thanks for having me on the program.

Guy Benson: All right. I want to start on this note, which crossed my timeline just last evening while I was on my way to an event in Washington, D.C. And the headline from CNN is, “U.S. Intel indicates Iran developing plans to potentially detonate a dirty bomb in Washington, sources say.” Here’s the beginning of the story: “New U.S. intelligence indicates that Iran is developing plans to target senior Trump administration officials by detonating a so-called dirty bomb or a chemical weapon in Washington, D.C., even as officials continue to debate whether Iran can or will attempt to execute such a plot, according to seven U.S. officials. Sources familiar with the latest intelligence categorized the Iranian planning as, for now, an effort to give itself options rather than an indicator of any imminent attack. But the plotting picked up by the U.S. has been very specific, includes locations and targets, two of those sources said, and has sparked a flurry of U.S. contingency planning.”

And then there’s a very sort of generic statement coming out of there, or “the possible threat of a dirty bomb in a major American city is of great concern.” I have extra concern because I live in this area. There are a lot of caveats in this reporting, and I know intelligence and figuring out and putting pieces together can be a very difficult and messy business. Let’s just start here with your background at the CIA. As you read this story, what strikes you, what stands out to you?

Daniel Hoffman: So the first thing is that we don’t know the timeline. And yes, Iran may have these sorts of plans, and the planning could have been discussed inside Iran. We may have a human source who told us that. We may have had signals intelligence–that is, chatter that we would have picked up, that NSA would have picked up. But the timeline is really important and there hasn’t been a whole lot that has been divulged. Perhaps we know something about the timeline, but we don’t want to reveal it to the public. How far along was this, is this plot?

We know that Iran is seeking to do us harm all over the world. They have launched assassination plots against retired senior officials as well as currently serving President Trump. We are in Iran’s crosshairs because we are at war with Iran and Iran’s terrorist proxies, the Houthis, Hezbollah, and they maintain this asymmetric capability to launch attacks on us that they believe gives them leverage in their relationship with us. So this is one to be concerned about. I think that this, along with all the other outages I’m sure you’ll be discussing today, it really warrants a public appearance from the Director of National Intelligence. Clear some talking points that are unclassified. Tell us what you can tell us. That dirty bomb threat impacts, as you noted, all of us who live in this city. And so we do, as concerned citizens, want to know a little bit more than we do. And we’d rather not be speculating about it.

Guy Benson: Right, because the way this was written–and they’ve got four bylines citing seven sources–is that it’s like Iran is developing plans that they might want to do this, but it’s unclear if they can actually do this or have the ability to do it or have decided they are going to do it, or they’re just talking about it to give themselves an option for a threat, right? There’s just a lot of ambiguity there. There’s also this reference to either a dirty bomb or chemical weapons. Those are different things. What’s the distinction there? What’s a dirty bomb, for example?

Daniel Hoffman: First of all, I just want to highlight that the reason why you want to get the information out to the American public is because we do have this concept here of like, “see something, say something.” So lots of tips that come to the FBI result from citizens who just happen to see something because they were told that, hey, you should be on the lookout for whatever is of concern to us. Now, a dirty bomb–that’s like… and by the way, before you get to the dirty bomb, I just want to–

Guy Benson: Fortify something that you just said. What was it, weeks ago in the UK, someone apparently reportedly saw something, said something, and there was, we believe, an Iranian-led plot to attack an Air Force base over there. So, you know, that goes to your point–the Iranians are trying things. Now it’s unclear what that plot exactly entailed and it was not successful, and they seemed actually very amateurish and they got rounded up, and then some of them were released–that’s a whole separate question. But the words “dirty bomb” echo a certain way, of course. So let’s get to that.

Daniel Hoffman: Yeah, I mean, that’s when you combine some conventional explosive with radioactive material; you’re going to scatter the contamination where it detonates. It’s not a nuclear weapon, but it can be improvised from radioactive nuclear waste. Now, where would that come from? I don’t know. Does Iran want that information to be out there, to try to perhaps frighten U.S. citizens and maybe induce some Americans not to want to support continued conflict with Iran? I don’t know what the motivation would have been. But that certainly is a tricky one to deliver into the United States, because you’re going to have to have some sort of radioactive nuclear waste material that you’re going to use.

Guy Benson: Them intentionally having this picked up in order for something like this to leak to scare a bunch of people–and whether they ever have any ability or intention on doing anything, just the notion of it is frightening enough that they feel like they might achieve something potentially just by that.

Daniel Hoffman: Yeah, they want to put the Trump administration back on their heels. They want to demonstrate that they can get to us and hurt our citizens, and they want to show that even though we’ve blown up a lot of their artillery and their missile capacity and their drones and their nuclear program, that they still retain enough weapons of mass destruction that they would say that they can inflict harm on us. That’s just part of the IRGC playbook.

Now I can tell you that all of this is being assessed at the CIA by Director Ratcliffe and his team of analysts. And they would be advising the president on exactly what Iran has the capability to do, what their motives might be. All of that is really important for us to understand our adversaries. We continue in this ongoing conflict with the Iranians, which is absolutely not going to end anytime soon. I think they see great value in continuing to be in a state of war with the United States.

Guy Benson: Okay, so you mentioned some of the outages. We go back to Microsoft Outlook and other platforms last week. Then of course all the FAA stuff. We just had a briefing from Secretary Duffy a few minutes ago. We monitored that. We might play some sound later. That was a big one. That one affected me and millions of people. Then some lower-level ones, right? Kind of lower-grade situations, but still getting attention, whether it was Chase Bank, United Airlines the other day. There are reports about Apple experiencing some problems today, and all these entities come out and they say, “Oh, we have no evidence of a cyber attack. This was some sort of internal problem or an upgrade or an update gone wrong.”

And I’m sitting here thinking… okay, maybe, maybe not. Maybe there were a couple big ones and then the smaller ones seem bigger–lower-level stuff that we normally ignore that’s kind of par for the course gets blown up into something much more concerning-seeming because people are looking for it. But then you get a story–it’s another CNN exclusive, and it was written up by the Daily Mail. You just mentioned a few minutes ago the National Security Agency, the NSA. Right. “The NSA’s top secret communications network has gone down with staff being warned of a heightened threat level amid growing global panic over escalating cyber chaos. The NSANet network, which employees use for highly classified internal communications, went down Tuesday morning after experiencing a ‘temporary degradation during scheduled routine maintenance,’ the NSA said.” And then people blew that whistle to CNN and it’s gone elsewhere. Again, you know, Dan, maybe this is all coincidental and maybe this was just routine maintenance and something, you know, went amiss or something like that. Or there’s a lot of things happening around the same time for a reason, and the denials at some point start to sound silly or not terribly credible. Are people reading too deeply into this or is there something going on?

Daniel Hoffman: So let’s start with this. Every single entity you describe is under cyber threat every single day, every moment of every single day. The Iranians, Russians, North Koreans, and the Chinese, not to mention criminal hackers, are targeting all of these entities and more–U.S. private sector in the crosshairs. We’re all in the crosshairs. Every single one of us. How many times do you have to patch your iPhone? Well, that’s because we’re under threat. And I’m sorry to say that all of these threats that we’re seeing here, we may not have been able to attribute them to a specific nefarious actor, but it doesn’t mean that those were not cyber threats and that we are not in incident response phase. When you’ve got to shut down NSANet, that probably means that there’s a concern about a penetration. And so they took some remedial action. We don’t know the details about that.

Again, this is another case where the Director of National Intelligence–we haven’t seen a lot of him–it would do well, it will do the administration well for him to get up in front of the American people, get behind the podium and explain to us to the extent that he can what’s going on. Answer just a few general questions because we live in a democracy and we kind of need to know what’s going on with our banks and tell us whether and how we’re under threat. I can tell you our adversaries know all about it and it’s never good when they do and we don’t as citizens. And it’s not going to hurt the ability that we have to do something about it if you tell the American people a little bit more than you have. So I think transparency is a good thing in this case. And a lack of transparency is a real problem, and you can bet that the Congress will be getting after this, especially starting in January, when Democrats will be questioning Trump administration officials maybe harshly on these sorts of things.

Guy Benson: Well, it also just, even before that, right, it starts to fuel theories and panic in some cases, and all sorts of stuff, if you’re not countering it with anything that seems straightforward, especially when there’s kind of one thing after another. The last question I have–and we’ll have to get you back here soon, because we’re not gonna even have time to touch on Nvidia and that whole potential espionage scandal. We’ll probably get to it later with Gordon Chang, but I’m dying to hear your thoughts on that. So Christine, let’s book him again. But Dan, very quickly, we have two or three minutes left. Yep. I know that some people are saying with AI, there’s a lot of people out there who are maybe hackers, nefarious actors, using AI to find vulnerabilities very efficiently and humans cannot keep up with that. So you would probably have to use AI to combat AI. A lot of Americans might say, “You know what, maybe we’re going too fast on AI, let’s shut this down or slow it down.” That could be a very popular idea, which is exactly what, for example, the Chinese would love us to do. I’m of two minds: like, is AI getting out of control too quickly and therefore do we tap the brakes and figure it out, or is this potentially part of some goal by the Chinese or someone else to plant that seed, have us overreact, and let them take the lead in the vital AI race? I don’t know what’s true, but that’s on my mind.

Daniel Hoffman: I’ll give you some food for thought when you talk to Gordon Chang because he’s an expert on this. Three things I think the Chinese wanted to do with the Nvidia operation. One, for sure, steal our secrets. That’s what they do. Second, influence U.S. policy. They got a lot of chips sent to Malaysia to their cutout company, Megaspeed. The third thing is every operation ends. When I was at CIA, we never planned for any operation to last forever. Sometimes you exfiltrate your source, sometimes the source retires. God forbid the source gets caught. In this case, they never tried to hide the relationship between Nvidia’s CEO, Jensen Huang, and Alice Wong. And they knew that at some point, this thing was gonna blow up. And that, at the end of the day, is the way they wanted this to end, because there’s a massive negative impact on Nvidia. Look at how the shares have fallen. They’ve lost, what, half a trillion dollars in stock. That’s the way China wants to do this, is to damage the linchpin of AI in the United States by damaging Nvidia’s reputation.

Guy Benson: As they did. Or a goal. Yeah, that is definitely food for thought. Hold that thought. Please come back soon. Dan Hoffman, former CIA station chief. Thank you.