Full Interview:
Full Transcript:
Guy Benson: Well, we’re joined now by Julian Epstein, who was chief counsel to the House Judiciary Committee and a staff director to the House Oversight Committee under the Democrats in the late 90s and early 2000s. Julian, good to have you back here.
Julian Epstein: Hey Guy, it’s a pleasure being with you always. I always tend to learn something from you watching you on Fox and in our discussion. So it’s great to be back.
Guy Benson: That’s very kind of you to say and we like having you here as well, although we kind of have to talk through what happened two weeks ago tomorrow and commiserate a bit. I know that you were very concerned about the direction of your political party. Some of the races in particular were of great interest to you. We talked a lot about Michigan, the Senate race there, and that race, like almost all of them–basically every competitive race, and then some that didn’t seem competitive then became competitive–went one direction in this washout blue wave tsunami situation. And now you’ve got a party with enormous governing majorities in Congress at least coming into play starting in January, and I think you’ve got a lot of people now jockeying for sort of positions of power into the future, whether in leadership or at the presidential level, or really trying to influence which wing or part of the party ends up on top and kind of supreme. And there’s a lot of battles playing out right now for that control, and one of the proxy fights is this Chuck Schumer majority leader question. He says he’s got the votes. I’ve seen reporting that he’s got the votes; he just needs a majority of the incoming caucus to become majority leader. We’ve got this Chris Van Hollen from Maryland who is his challenger. He says that’s nonsense and he’s going to be fighting this thing out. He, of course, has been pandering hard to the progressive wing, the left-wingers on Israel. He’s turned sharply against Israel. He’s gone to bat for criminal illegal immigrants. He’s kind of gone, you know, face-first in the tank for the whole left-wing agenda. So that’s one of these battles that’s already brewing. How do you read it? And if in fact you do believe that Schumer’s fine, he’ll be fine and be elected, what kind of leash will he have? Because I know the base, right? The base reviles him.
Julian Epstein: Yeah, I think that’s the right question, Guy, and thanks again for having me on. I think the news media is missing what’s going on here. They’re treating this as a horse race, and it’s not a horse race–it’s a flex. It’s a flex by the progressives and the socialists in the party, and Schumer does have the votes. He’s probably got 29, which is the amount of votes that he needs.
Guy Benson: Some of the numbers have it higher and into like the upper 30s even, so we’ll see.
Julian Epstein: Yeah, what Van Hollen is trying to do on behalf of the socialists and the hard leftists is to tell Schumer that the caucus is divided and that if he wants to get anything done, Schumer is going to have to capitulate. He’s going to have to make major concessions to the hard left. Now, what those concessions are is yet to be determined. You’ve got people like Ron Wyden, who’s talking about spending $8 or $10 million–$8 to $10 trillion–on new tax-and-spend welfare spending. You’ve got a big portion of the Democratic caucus that wants to isolate Israel and take away its ability for self-defense in what is a war against fascism in the Middle East. You’ve sort of got the Green New Deal agenda that’s trying to be revived by the socialists. It’s not clear what exactly Van Hollen would do on behalf of the socialists and the hard left, but what he’s saying is, “I’ve got a group of 15, 20 senators who, if you want to get anything done, you’re going to have to capitulate to them.” And that’s what this is about.
Guy Benson: Medicare for All also being, you know, one of these demands you’re seeing creeping up on the left.
Julian Epstein: I tell you, that’s a con job. I don’t even think they’re going to bring Medicare for All up for a vote, because they tried to do this, I think it was 2019. And as soon as voters realize that it’s going to mean an end to their employer-based insurance and substitute it for a very lousy form of government-run insurance, the numbers turn immediately. They go, let’s say, 80-20 against it. And the Democrats know that this whole Medicare for All campaign slogan was a complete con job. I would bet a dollar to a donut that it never comes up for a vote.
Guy Benson: I think it may not come up for a vote in the upcoming Congress. I think they want to keep the idea alive, get the trifecta, and then do a lot of things if they can, including Medicare for All, but that’s–
Julian Epstein: Well, it’s grandstanding. It’s grandstanding, this demagoguery. They hope that the public doesn’t look at this the way they hope the public doesn’t look at the rest of what’s going on. I mean, the federal government is functionally insolvent right now. We’re $40 trillion in debt with $2 trillion every year adding on to that. We, you know, we are going in the direction of France very, very slowly, but surely. And you know, you look at the con job that’s being told by a welfare state that continues to fail. Obamacare was supposed to solve the problem for the uninsured and the underinsured, right? And what Obamacare has done is it’s killed competition, it’s increased consolidation, and it’s basically been a blank check for insurance companies.
Guy Benson: Well, and premiums keep going up. I saw there was like a double-digit premium increase this year under the quote-unquote Affordable Care Act, which is the last time Democrats–
Julian Epstein: They’re expecting 14%–I think the number is somewhere between 12 and 14%. But it stands to reason that this would happen, because basically what the federal government is saying to insurance companies is, “Charge whatever you like for the most part, and the consumer, the patient is only going to have to pay a small fraction of those costs, and the government will pay the rest.” And so it’s a blank check for insurance companies. And it was very foreseeable. Conservatives pointed that out at the time, but not loudly enough. I mean, the conservative message machine here during the midterms and even now is just horrible.
Guy Benson: I mean, I do think, in fairness, I do think conservatives won the argument on Obamacare and won huge majorities to try to stop it in 2010. But it was too late. Democrats jammed it through anyway. And I think they would love to do the same with a government takeover of health care if they have the votes–probably not again in the next two years, but thereafter, if they had all of those levers of power. But I just want to come back, because the Van Hollen thing, you’re calling it a flex. I started to identify him as someone with clear national ambitions the moment he started really turning on Israel, because that’s kind of the spirit of the base of the party right now, where you cannot go anywhere in national Democratic politics unless you are foaming at the mouth about the Jewish state. And then, you know, his stunt going down and having whatever the margaritas with the criminal alien, all of that. He is pandering to that very sizable base. They feel emboldened, and I know that the more moderate folks are saying, “Look, without us, we don’t have these big majorities.” I don’t think that the left-wingers care. I think the left-wingers are like, “We’ve got these majorities. We’ve shown that we can win even in a place like Michigan, and now we’ve got to govern like left-wing socialists, and if you’re not going to do it, you’re going to have big, big problems.” I feel like the Dems are going to have lots of wiggle room, right? Margin for error given the size of these majorities, but there are some underlying tensions that could bubble to the surface, especially in an upcoming presidential primary where you’re going to have a lot of people running that hard-left route to try to get to the White House and saying, “Listen, we can win. It doesn’t matter what we believe in, what we say. 2026 proves that this stuff can win nationwide.” And are they wrong?
Julian Epstein: Yeah, they’re wrong. And they’re wrong. I mean, the Democratic Party, Guy, continues to be 10 points behind the Republican Party in terms of public favorability and brand favorability.
Guy Benson: Yeah, they just won 56 Senate seats and 260 House seats, though.
Julian Epstein: That’s not because anything they’re doing is popular. That’s because people were repulsed by what Trump is doing, which is he is spending too much time on vanity projects and not enough time on a plan for the future. And he was god-awful in terms of explaining what was a very noble undertaking in Iran. This is something that has to be explained to the public, which wasn’t, except for these one-offs. And it was a rejection of Trump. It was not any kind of mandate or validation of what the Democrats were arguing. The Democrats continue to be far, far, far to the left of the median voter, much further left than the Republicans are to the right of the median. The Republicans align with the median voters much better than Democrats do, but you know, when we have more time, I could just go through the number of just dismal communications failures and strategic failures on the part of the Republican Party. I mean, the Republican Party was sort of right. I think that Trump was right on the economic plan in terms of deregulation and tax cuts. Look at the economy. We’re at 3.4 GDP growth. He was right on Iran. He is right on closed borders. But these things were poorly executed and poorly communicated. I wanted him to succeed on all these things because I think they were right, and I think also undermined–
Guy Benson: And also undermined by some other stuff as well, so like that’s–well, undermined by JD Vance, for sure.
Julian Epstein: Look, the worst mistake that this administration made was the pause on October 7th–I’m sorry, on April 7th–of the war, because we were, I think, a month away from finishing the job, and I think the administration was duped when Iran said, “Let’s talk,” and I think Qatar and Pakistan played a role in duping the administration, and so that was a disaster. That’s one issue, but let’s return back to what you were asking about Van Hollen. There’s one point that you missed about Van Hollen in terms of his flex, and the socialist agenda is all the flex. I don’t think any of it is a serious set of policy ideas that could ever pass or bring meaningful change. But the one idea that you missed was he wants to raise–he’s talking about raising the marginal tax rate to 50% at the federal level. Okay, when you put that together with state and local taxes, you’re talking about for the most productive amongst us, the job creators, you’re talking about a tax rate of 70% when you include state and local. That means that if you are the most productive, if you are a job creator, if you are an innovator, you are going to have to effectively work for the government between January and October. Right? You get two or three months out of the year where you’re actually making income that goes to yourself rather than the federal government.
Guy Benson: But Julian, a lot of people in your party would say that’s just a fair share and they can afford it. That’s the mantra.
Julian Epstein: Yeah. Well, I don’t think many of them understand economics. If you look at the people in the party saying that, none of them have ever spent any time in the private sector building, innovating, discovering anything. I agree, but like if they’ve got the–
Guy Benson: Power, they’re going to do it. This is what is…
Julian Epstein: Well, look at what happened. I mean, again, to the point about the Democrats not having a mandate, look what happened in California, look what happened with these wealth taxes. And one of the things that the Republican Party is not explaining–they’re very much on the defensive on this “tax the rich”–is, you know, if you’re a billionaire, right? And you’re making X amount in passive and active income, a tiny, tiny fraction of that income that you’re getting is being spent on your own personal consumption, whatever luxury you may have. A tiny fraction–90 to 95% of that is the money that goes back into the investment economy. The economy that’s going to provide the AI revolution, the economy that has to invest in our factories and providing new jobs. That is the engine of our economic growth. So, when they’re talking about taking 70% of what they earn and taking it from the productive investment economy and putting it into the unproductive welfare state economy, you’re talking about, again, going back in the direction of France that has less than 1%–
Guy Benson: No, I agree, Julian. I don’t disagree with anything that you’re saying. I just worry.
Julian Epstein: My point is not that you and I disagree, Guy; my point is that there is nobody out there on the Republican side making this argument in an effective way. You know, Milton Friedman used to make this argument on behalf of Ronald Reagan, and it was extremely effective. And it was extremely persuasive, including–even though they didn’t want to admit it–with liberals, moderate liberals in that time. This argument is not being joined in a meaningful way by people that oppose it. And that is why it’s gaining currency amongst particularly a Gen Z population that is looking for easy answers, that does not study, that doesn’t have any depth of understanding, and that is frankly in many cases a lazy generation. And until people start countering this nonsense with reality, it’s going to continue.
Guy Benson: Now you’ve got to address the real frustrations, which do exist, but you’ve got to do it on substance with ideas that work. That’s not, I think, what we’ve seen, especially in this cycle, which brings us again, looking ahead. We talked about sort of this skirmish over Senate leadership; I think that’s small potatoes compared to the presidential race. I was on TV earlier today. I think there’s this report out that the DSA chapter in New York is urging AOC to run for president. I think she is strongly considering it. And I think that she could get the nomination. I’m not saying she’s destined to get it, but if it’s seen as Bernie Sanders handing her the torch and it’s a very crowded field and she’s got a lot of energy and, you know, young leftists behind her, I could see a path to the nomination. And if the electorate is in a mood two years from now like they were two weeks ago, I think she could win a general election. Do you disagree?
Julian Epstein: I completely disagree. First of all, just circling back to my point about the DSA and the conservative communications machine. I mean, every time you talk about the DSA endorsing somebody, one of the first things that opponents should be out there saying, which I’ve said, is that the DSA is an organization that supports fascism. The DSA cheered for the October 7th massacre, which is based on an ideology that goes directly back to Nazi Germany. The 1988 Hamas Charter is a direct descendant of Mein Kampf, and nobody makes that argument. If this was an organization that was supporting a genocide against Black or brown folks, every time they did anything, it’s the first thing the left would remind you of, and yet the right and moderates don’t say anything.
Guy Benson: And they’re also super radical on policing and prisons and all. I mean, you go down the list, their entire agenda is crazy.
Julian Epstein: Yeah, look at Mamdani with the response to the special response unit in New York. No question. But I think more importantly with AOC is I don’t think AOC is a very serious candidate. I don’t think she has a great deal of depth or substance, and there’s plenty of examples of that. When she was asked about strategic ambiguity in Taiwan, she had no clue what that was. When she was asked a couple years ago on a show called Firing Line about the situation in Gaza and the West Bank, she fumbled her way through. It was clear she didn’t even have a freshman college student’s understanding of the issue. She was a bartender before she was a member of Congress. And any time she’s in a situation where she’s asked on serious policy issues to explain something, she sort of, you know, lapses into a Kamala Harris evasion or stream of consciousness or something that is other than, you know, deep-think substance. So I think she is an influencer. I mean, that’s the unfortunate thing about what’s happening in our politics is we have entered into an influencer era where–
Guy Benson: I agree, which is why I think, Julian, we could have an influencer election if we haven’t already had one, and if the political mood is aligned a certain way, I think a very substanceless, destructive-ideology-type candidate could win. That’s a discussion we can continue to have and then have that debate over the next couple of years because I think that conversation is coming. Julian Epstein, longtime Democratic operative here on The Guy Benson Show with us. Julian, thank you so much for your time.





